Looking for something? Search this site and archives.

Electoral Fraud and the (Un)Fair Election Act of 2014

by Derek Skinner
(Victoria, BC)

Electoral Fraud

Pierre Poilievre, as Minister of State for Democratic Reform, is responsible for introducing "The (Un)Fair Election Act". He is just the last in a string of conservative hacks who have been quietly modifying the Elections Act since the 2006 Harper Minority Government took office.

The In/Out scandal of the 2006 election showed the utter contempt the CPC (Conservative Party of Canada) and its backers had for Canadian law as enunciated in the Election Act.

Elections Canada financial auditors, following standard procedures for reviewing election campaign spending for the General Election of 2006, determined that more than 60 CPC financial reports showed election spending violations. The audits showed that CPC 'apparatchics' like Doug Findly and Irving Gerstein sent party money into the campaign accounts of candidates. They instructed the candidates to direct their agents to use the money to buy advertising with the exact same message that the CPC had used and had spent the maximum allowable under law buying for the national media campaign.

This was an obvious circumvention of the rules in the Act limiting advertising by political parties. The CPC knew this because they were advised by Elections Canada before they did it that it was illegal. Their own lawyers told them that it was illegal, others told them that is was illegal. They did it anyway.

Four months after the General Election of 2006, the scheme would have been clear to the Chief Electoral Officer of Canada at the time, Jean Pierre Kingsley. The remedy prescribed in the Elections Act at the time called for anyone participating in such a scheme to be disqualified as a candidate for a period of two years and to be disqualified from taking a seat in the House for a period of two years, to be made to pay a fine of $2,000 and/or to spend up to two years in Jail.

Jean Pierre Kingsley had a tough choice to make; he could declare the Election invalid or he could resign. He chose the latter.

Harper was allowed by the Governor General to form an illegal minority government. That government appointed a new Chief Electoral Officer, Marc Mayrand, and on Dec. 12th 2006 passed the Director of Public Prosecutions Act as Part 3 of the Federal Accountability Act which transferred the ability to prosecute Elections Act offences from Elections Canada to a newly created (appointed by Harper) Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (DPP).

Marc Mayrand, as mandated by the Elections Act, dutifully proceeded with the investigation of the "In and Out" scheme and the DPP did, in the end, lay charges against several CPC members who pleaded guilty to lesser offences and paid fines.

While all this was going on, the CPC attacked and vilified Marc Mayrand as if he was a stooge of the Liberal Party. The allegation was absurd, but the media toadied right along and the broader Canadian public was completely misled.

Because of the many changes in Voter residences, in 1995, Elections Canada assigned a ten digit unique, permanent, stable ID number to every voter in an internal data base. CPC changes to the Act externalized those numbers and they are now posted in the Voter Registration Lists which are supplied to every Party. The numbers make it easy for Parties to keep track of Voter's movements and views, functioning like a national ID card and they employ willing American corporations to do just that.

Successive Bills have been passed by the Harper Government that severely restrict the ability of political parties other than the CPC to raise money. The 2003 regime that subsidized political parties on a per-vote basis was dismantled. The CPC advocates for and defends the rich, who have money to spend on political parties, while those parties that advocate for the rest of us have to beg for money from people who already do not have enough.

Other quiet changes to the Election Act resulted in the "Bingo Card" scheme and the resulting Robocalls. The so-called Bingo Cards are issued by Elections Canada every 30 minutes during Election Day, listing the voters who have voted so far during the day. This enables Party organizers to mobilize last minute efforts to get out the pro-Party vote if they see that the result will be close. It also enables Robocalls to be started to any remaining voters who may vote against the party.

When the Bingo Card proposal was introduced to the Advisory Committee of Political Parties (ACPP) in 2007, as part of Bill C31, many members of the ACPP spoke forcefully against the scheme. In particular, the Canadian Action Party member stated that with sophisticated pre-polling, the Bingo Card scheme not only allowed political parties to know who has voted and exactly when in an election but, to a very fine statistical probability, the Bingo Card would allow political parties to know how voters had voted. This would take us within a hair's breadth of a ballot that was no longer secret.

Some 1400 complaints of misleading Robocalls, from ridings across Canada, were registered with Elections Canada. The Council of Canadians and others have identified at least 7 ridings where multiple Robocalls very likely resulted in a false election. Further an extraordinary number of ridings across the country were won or lost by razor-thin margins where Robocalls misdirecting voters other than CPC supporters were known to have occurred. Other parties made Robocalls too but none of those calls were made to misdirect voters.

The CPC announced on a Friday afternoon in November of 2013 that they had dumped the database in question as the source of the voter suppression Robocalls. No doubt the Commissioner of Elections investigating the Robocalls had telegraphed that he would be seeking to acquire access to the database as part of his investigation, an investigation the CPC has fought tooth and nail every step of the way, all the while vilifying Elections Canada and requiring the Commissioner, Ives Cote, to seek court orders for release of every piece of the puzzle in the hands of the CPC.

Now the "Fair Elections Act", as proposed, will shake 'undesirables' out of the voters lists by raising barriers for people not likely to vote for the CPC; i.e. young people unable to get a decent job and possibly progressive or even radical, poor people who cannot afford a car and so do not have a driver's license or carry a passport for photo ID or other sanctioned documents that identify a current residential address, aboriginal people likely resentful of bad treatment and new Canadians and others who will not be able to have people vouch for them. All this is quite ridiculous in light of the unique permanent ID number.

By Elections Canada's estimates the first rendition of the new voter rules in Bill C31 (2007) shook 2.2 million voters off the list. Taking away "vouching" as proposed in C23 will shake off another 100,000.

The proposed 2014 Act goes on to increase the restrictions on Election Canada's power to inform voters on many issues other than "the date of the election and where is their polling station". It also moves the authority to investigate electoral irregularities away from Elections Canada to the office of the DPP, further slowing response time in investigations and prosecutions and confusing the public about who runs what in government.

Essentially it will not matter what the law says, the enforcement will take so long the law will be moot. Now Poilievre has the effrontery to imply that the Chief Electoral Officer is showing bias because he has criticized some of the causes in the Act and is trying to do his job without bowing to the dictates of the CPC.

All this sleaze and manipulation of the Elections Act is going on while the corporate media is largely silent.

Is this how you want your democracy to be watered down for the benefit of one Party that is trying to ensure that it will maintain a majority control of Parliament for ever?

If this bothers you, call your MP – particularly if he/she is a CPC member – and demand that they stop passage of the Fair Elections Act.

Derek Skinner, Victoria BC 15/02/2014
P.S. Thanks to Will Arlow and Paul McMurray for their clarifications and corrections.

Comments for Electoral Fraud and the (Un)Fair Election Act of 2014

Click here to add your own comments

Feb 25, 2014
Electoral Act
by: Maurice

Well prepared and well written piece on the Conservative Government's attempt to mislead Canadians into forgetting their election frauds committed in the last election.

Click here to add your own comments

Join in and write your own page! It's easy to do. How? Simply click here to return to Writer Submission.

Return to the Dialogue Home Page

What is Dialogue Magazine?

The Summer Edition has been mailed out. [You can order a copy of the printed magazine!]

The coming Autumn Edition will begin our 28th year; some of the "E" topics suggested so far:  Earth, Eden, Equality, Elections, ET Encounters, Electric Universe... Other Ideas?  Target deadline: August 1st. Please email letters, articles, poetry, art, photography, etc. to: dialogue@dialogue.ca
MAIL: 6227 Groveland Dr., Nanaimo, BC V9V 1B1 CANADA. Or use the Submission Page.


"NO PIPELINES" EVENTS IN BC - JUNE 25-27 [Galiano, Victoria, Vancouver] Details and Background from Zoe Blunt / via June Ross.

* * *

The Green Party position on the Northern Gateway pipeline decision, at RAW/CBC:  Jun 17, 2014: "Elizabeth May says the pipeline project is a 'dangerous scheme' and not in Canada's economic interest" -
CBC Article

* * *

JUNE 20, 2014
"Fair" Elections Act will face Charter challenge from the Council of Canadians & Cdn. Federation of Students: [COC media release] The “Fair” Elections Act received Royal Assent & became law  (June 19), but is already facing a Charter challenge... the COC & the Cdn. Federation of Students – will ask a court to strike down key sections. The legal challenge will target central provisions of the Act: the prohibition on the use of a Voter Information Card to prove residency and the muzzling of the Chief Electoral Officer (CEO). [...]

* * *

JUNE 14, 2014

SMART GRID PROTEST DAY A 'REAL' SMART METER RALLY was held on June 14 - to support everyone's HUMAN RIGHT to OPT OUT of the undemocratic provincially-mandated SMART METER program. Rallies will include prominent speakers and activities.- from Citizens for Safe Technology

* * *

JUNE 1-8 was World Oceans Week; World Oceans Day is June 8th! Enjoy live underwater ocean cameras and read how Canada was instrumental in creating World Water Day, in 1992.

* * *

March Against Monsanto on May 24: millions of people gathered to protest the despicable food imperialism practices of  Monsanto.  naturalnews.com

* * *

MAY 13, 2014:
Watch Elizabeth May's - speech in Parliament on the Fair Elections Act, Bill C-23.

* * *

MAY 12, 2014: Welcome to Nulandistan: A Multimedia look at what the US & EU have unleashed on Ukraine - Read at Global Research.

* * *

Council of Canadians - Stop the UnFair Elections Act! Demand Truly Fair Elections: PETITION

* * *

APR. 25, 2014
Breaking News from Leadnow re change to "Fair Elections" Act

* * *

APR. 25, 2014

APR. 25,2014 Is the USA now an oligarchy?
By Danny Schechter, at Global Research: The word 'Oligarchy' has finally come home. For years, it was a term only used in connection with those big bad and sleazy Mafioso-type businessmen in Russia... READ MORE

* * *

APR. 23, 2014
From S. McDowall:
"Prepping for a Ukrainian Massacre" By Robert Parry, at InformationClearingHouse "Between the anti-Russian propaganda pouring forth from the Obama administration and the deeply biased coverage from the U.S. news media, the American people are being prepared to accept and perhaps even cheer a massacre of eastern Ukrainians who have risen up against the coup regime in Kiev. READ MORE

* * *

APR. 22, 2014 FOREST WALKING FOR HEALTH "Medical studies prove forest walking boosts immunity ... studies which began in Japan sought to find the physiological impact of forest bathing..." 
See more - Article by Jonathan Landsman, NaturalHealth365

* * *

APR. 20, 2014
Susan McCaslin's essay on Easter & the Emergence
of Christ Consciousness,
"Reversing The Last Supper" - from the Spring Edition

* * *

APR. 12, 2014
Robin Matthews on the Death of Democracy in Canada - and the legacy of James Michael Flaherty:

"Let us not confuse respect for the dead with blindness to history..."

* * *

APR. 12, 2014 Kitimat votes NO to Pipeline in plebecite:

READ ABOUT the DOGWOOD Initiative for a province-wide vote on tanker & pipeline expansion

Jeremy  Arney's Presentation to the Pipeline Review Panel

* * *

20 years ago, the US was behind the genocide-Rwanda: Installing a US Proxy State in Central Africa,
by Prof Michel Chossudovsky, Global Research, April 6, 2014


* * *

APR. 6, 2014
"Media Blackout over Syria" - Brad Hoff at Global Research, on Seymour Hersh's exposé in the London Review of Books.

* * *

VIDEO: Jessica Ernst exposes drilling & fracking crimes in Alberta, Mar. 25, 2014 - LINK from Robin Mathews (on April 5, 2014)

* * *

Derek Skinner's article, Electoral Fraud: about recent and ongoing assaults against Canadian electoral integrity; and about the proposed (Un)Fair Elections Act.

* * *

Add comments or new items in Your Submissions

You can add & view events at the Current Events page.


Take action to keep Big Oil & Mining out of BC Parks


See article in the Vancouver Observer: Bill 4 Passes, opens B.C. parks to industry, by Carol Linnitt Mar 25th, 2014

SumOfUs Petition: "A law was just passed that gives oil, gas and mining companies the power to open up BC’s provincial parks for industrial activity. Resource companies will now be able to drill exploratory wells, build roads and dig giant test pits, all in the name of pipeline & transmission line 'research.'  Unless we act now to repeal this law, some of the most beautiful parks in Canada could be opened up to industrial development. This could set a dangerous national precedent as oil, gas & mining companies scramble to extract as many fossil fuel resources as possible from deep below the soil...  Read more & sign the SumOfUs Petition:

Why not start an Initiative to rescind Bill 4...
BC's Recall and Initiative Act allows registered voters in BC to propose new laws or changes to existing laws within the jurisdiction of the BC Legislature. Let's start an Initiative to rescind the Park Amendment Act.

Stop Bill C-18

Bill C-18, the “Agricultural Growth Act” omnibus bill, amending several federal agricultural laws, was introduced in Parliament on December 9, 2013. If passed, it will give multi-national agri-business much more money, power and control while increasing farmers’ costs and reducing farmers’ autonomy and Canadian sovereignty.
The Bill passed Second reading (House), as of March 3, 2014
Visit the NFU link below for information about Bill C-18 and its implications as well as about how the NFU's proposed Farmers Seed Act can be used as a Toolkit to help organize opposition to the Bill. LINK: